Most ATs suck in the mud. I've had very similar results with BFG ATs to Yello's post above. My Cooper STs actually did pretty good in mud, but they weren't true mudders.
Nope. They have all gone on to other owners. I have a 2000 2Door that is going to be my next project. I want to take the back half off of the roof and do a cage interior... These are just from the last 3 years.
Unfortunately the last one looks like this now.